The cartoon opens with a voice-over by Bugs Bunny explaining that strange carrots have traveled from outer space to Earth. Afterwards, Bugs goes to his classic routines about outsmarting Elmer Fudd. During the routines, Bugs takes notice of a strange pile of glowing carrots, but ignores them. The next day, Bugs wakes up and returns to his routines, but Elmer appears as a poorly drawn version of himself, including possessing strangely friendly attitudes and offers Bugs Bunny a carrot. Bugs eventually accepts and takes the carrot home with him. The carrot rips open and expels a poorly drawn version of Bugs. The impostor attempts to kill the real Bugs with an axe and Bugs runs off screaming. Bugs finds tags reading "Made on Planet Nudnik" on the Elmer replacement, who have devolved into mindlessly spouting their catchphrases like a broken record. Bugs catches the impostors in a bag labeled "pale stereotypes" and sends it into outer space, where it gets swallowed by a black hole. The following morning, Bugs wakes up to find Elmer back to normal.
- Bugs Bunny (voiced by Jeff Bergman)
- Elmer Fudd (voiced by Billy West)
- The Black Hole (voiced by Frank Welker)
- "(coming from the Warner Bros. Animation sheild) Wait, hold it! (stops the logo with a control remote) You would think that I would end that, did you? I just got to find out what's behind this (channel flips back to the forest)" - Bugs Bunny.